How might we reimagine the commuting experience for young professionals taking public transportation?
Using Design Thinking methods, our team reimagined the riding experience of the Bay Area Rapid Transit system (BART) for young commuters. We redesigned the interior colors and lighting, and developed a supporting business model - including the ads installation in the form of murals.
User Research, Prototyping, User Testing, Visual Design
observe & Notice
From some quick research on the internet, we learned about the public’s opinion on commuting, what are the common pain points, and especially commuting in the bay area. Here are some of our key insights:
Current status of the BART: a lot of riders are commuters to work
Increased numbers of commuters: New York and San Francisco had the strongest.
The average commute time in the bay area is around 30 minutes.
Worn down public transportation contributes to traffic.
Health and hygiene are big concerns.
What affects transportation: colors & art
We also conducted interviews with commuters in the age group of 18-30 to understand their experiences with the BART and commuting in general. Here’s what they had to say:
Safety seems to be a concern - people wants to feel comfortable
The interior seems dull and depressing
We can learn from the public transport systems in foreign countries
frame & Reframe
Synthesis to define the problem space.
Drawing from the insights gained from our initial research and interviews, we narrowed down our target user group to young adults entering the workforce. After synthesizing, we came to the question: How might we reimagine the commuting experience for young professionals taking public transportation?
As we continue to develop our idea, we started to focus on the interior aspect of the BART. We did more research to learn about interior visual aspects like lighting and colors to better inform our future design decisions. Here’s a high-level overview of what we found:
Illuminate: an interesting business that has done some cool LED light art installation.
Since the Bay Area has such a diverse cultural mix, we also learned about some cultural contexts for colors.
Imagine & Design
To better understand the needs and pain points of our target users, we built a persona representing young adults entering the workforce.
Location: San Francisco Bay Area
Recent Cal grad, Bio-E and Cog Sci major
Current consultant at a biotech consulting company
Daily commuter between Berkeley and San Francisco
(I also wrote a pitch with a short story reimagining Risha's experience with BART after the revamp.)
To attempt to solve the problem, we tried to come up with as many ideas as possible using methods like brainstorming, journey map, AEIOU, and system mapping.
To converge, we used a decision matrix to evaluate the effectiveness of some of the ideas based on the following elements: cost & profitability, visual aesthetics, functionality, space availability, cleanliness, storage capability, accessibility, and comfort.
We also looked at public transit systems in other cities and countries, and discussed what worked and what didn’t.
We decided to focus on the idea of improving perceived aspects like safety, comfort, and cleanliness through changing the visual interior aspect of the BART, especially colors and lightings.
To fund and support the revamp of BART interior, we also built a business model, which includes installing murals in the interior of the BART, with sponsored logos from corporate partners like companies in the Bay Area.
The idea here is that the young commuters can enjoy the art and feel empowered as they work toward their goals, while our corporate partners would sponsor part of the revamp project.
Make & Experiment
After attempts to get in touch with BART officials, in the lack of approval to do prototype testing on the actual BART, we decided to visualize our idea through both digital and physical prototypes.
We photoshopped images of the BART interior to demonstrate the difference colors and brighting can make:
We also 3D printed a small model of the interior to show our idea of improved lighting and colors, although unfortunately we have lost the picture of the final product.
To test out the effectiveness of our idea and collect feedbacks from our target user group, we created an online survey, and distributed it through our social media.
We asked questions like how often do they ride the BART, their main reason of travel, and how strongly do they agree to some statements regarding BART:
The current color scheme of BART puts me in a positive mood
A different color scheme of BART could put me in a more positive mood
A different color scheme of BART could make me feel safer riding on BART
A different color scheme of BART could make me ride the BART more often redesign were affective, I asked the two users with different amount of usages of Airbnb to use the prototype, and observed their interaction with it.
From the 70 surveys that we've collected, we got an overall positive feedback on a new and improved BART interior:
78% agreeing that a different color scheme will put them in a better mood
76% agreeing that brighter lighting will put them in a better mood
At the end of the class, we presented our project to students, faculties, and industry professionals at the 2016 Jacobs Winter Design Showcase.
We even had the opportunity to speak with a representative from BART, who recognized the problems that we've brought forth, took notes from our project, and gave us some feedbacks on the feasibility of our project.
I enjoyed working with my team members, who are from different academic backgrounds, each with a unique set of skills and knowledge that contributed to the project.
We also explored different design methodologies during the ideation phase. Most importantly, I got comfortable working with ambiguities as we went through different iterations and the design cycle. Though there were some hardships, we were all proud to present our final result at the showcase after all.
Starting off with the broad, wicked problem "how might we improve commuting?", our team struggled trying to define a proper problem space. In fact, we went through two cycles of iterations, first targeting specific physical components of the BART like handles, poles, and seating arrangement. It turns out to be too specific, and rendered few options that were neither cohesive enough to form a final solution, nor strong enough to stand alone. Luckily, we pivoted (few weeks before the final showcase) and landed on our final "how might we" question, and at the end, were able to present a solid project at the showcase.
If we were doing this again, I'd wish that we have more time to explore some of the other options that came up during the diverging process in the ideation phase.